1501 Brighton Rd · California-Kirkbride, PITTSBURGH · Parcel 0023J00003000000 · LNC zoning · 2,337 sq ft lot
By right, this lot allows one single-family home, and at current costs it comes up short by about $152,000; construction at about $250 per finished sq ft is the main cost.
A 3-unit building would need a variance for the parking per unit, and nearby requests like this have usually been approved (26 of 29 approved in LNC since 2025).
Easiest option by the Ease Score: New single-family house, 96 (Easy).
Preparing the full study (site, zoning, market, budget, returns, risks and appendices); this parcel is being analyzed for the first time…
Development Feasibility Study
1501 Brighton Rd
California-Kirkbride, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
Parcel ID
0023J00003000000
Zoning
LNC — Local Neighborhood Commercial
Date
September 27, 2026
Scenario studied
Single-family house, 1 unit, 3 stories, new construction, for sale
Lot
2,337 sq ft
Lot plan with the buildable area and the studied footprint. The true-scale site plan is sheet EA-101 in Section 3.
Decision support — not legal, financial, or engineering advice. This study screens a parcel with public data and published rules. It is not an appraisal, a zoning determination, a survey or an engineering report. Every number is footnoted to its source in Appendix A. Costs are editable defaults with a source label on each; values marked “not included” or “awaiting” are not yet known and are never filled with guesses. Prepared by the EaseScore.AI engine · report v0.1.
This study looks at building single-family house, 1 unit, 3 stories, new construction on the 2,337 sq ft[4] lot at 1501 Brighton Rd in California-Kirkbride.
In two sentences
By right, this lot allows one single-family home, and at current costs it comes up short by about $152,000; construction at about $250 per finished sq ft is the main cost. A 3-unit building would need a variance for the parking per unit, and nearby requests like this have usually been approved (26 of 29 approved in LNC since 2025).[5, 6, 7]
Summary of the calculated results. Decision support only, not legal, financial or engineering advice. Confirm zoning with the City and costs with local bids.
Product types compared
Each column runs the same cost builder and finance engine with the default assumptions[6, 8]. By right means no hearing; “with approval” is the option that fits the most homes with zoning relief[3, 7]. The affordable column rents the by-right building at the tax-credit rent limit[9]; its funding gap needs loan terms (Section 10). These layouts come from the Ease Score’s site-fit check, so their size can differ from the scheme studied in Sections 7 to 9.
Table 1. By-right best vs. with-approval best vs. affordable
Measure
Best by right
Best with approval
Affordable (60% AMI rental)
Building
New single-family house
3-4 unit building
One single-family home, rented at $1,722 a month (3 BR limit, 2026)
Homes
1
3
1
Zoning path
Allowed by right
Needs a variance for the parking per unit
Allowed by right
Past decisions
Not needed
Nearby requests like this have usually been approved (26 of 29 approved in LNC since 2025)
—
Total development cost
2Project scenario
The scenario is the building this study tests. Unless you chose one, it is the scheme our site-fit solver ranked first for the goal “most homes”[3].
Table 2. The studied scenario
Strategy
Single-family house
Building type
Single-family house
Homes (units)
1
Unit size on the ground
20 ft wide × 54 ft deep
Stories / height
3 stories, about 35 ft
Floor area
3,240 sq ft gross; 2,542 sq ft livable (net)
Parking
Tuck-under garage: 1 space (1 required)
Lot split
Not needed
Lot coverage
46%
Zoning status
Allowed by right
What limits it
The lot's width is the limit on this single-family house..
Sale or rent
Built to sell
Affordable mode
Off
Changed from defaults
Building type set to single-family house
Solver warnings for this scheme
1 tuck-under garage at street level; one driveway straight from the curb.
Other building types that fit
Table 3. Best scheme for each building type[3]
Building type
Homes
Gross sq ft
Stories
Parking
Zoning
Limited by
Single-family house
1
3,240
3
1 garage
By right
The lot's width is the limit on this single-family house.
Duplex
2
3,600
3
1 garage
Needs approval
The lot's width is the limit on this duplex.
3–4 unit building
3
4,200
3
1 garage
Needs approval
The lot's width is the limit on this 3–4 unit building.
3Site analysis
3.1 Location and neighborhood
1501 Brighton Rd is in California-Kirkbride, 25th Ward - Pittsburgh[14, 15]. In its census tract (5652), the median household income is $92,500, the median rent is $1,130 a month, and 20.3% of homes are vacant; 25.2% of renters spend more than 30% of income on rent[16].
3.2 Lot size and shape
The county lists the lot at 2,340 sq ft[14]; the GIS outline measures 2,337 sq ft[4]. It has 4 sides, with 20 ft and 20 ft of street frontage. No building stands on the lot in the county footprint data.
The site plan (sheet EA-101, at the end of this section) draws the lot to scale at 1″ = 20′: lot lines and dimensions, zoning setbacks, the buildable area, the studied footprint, neighboring buildings, the street, 2-foot lidar contours, ground steeper than 25% and mapped hazard limits. Keynotes on the sheet explain each item.
3.3 Terrain
From 1-meter lidar, the lot’s average slope is 6.8%, and the steepest 5% of it is over 12%[17]. 0% of the lot is steeper than 25%, the line where Pittsburgh’s grading rules and most builders start to treat ground as steep; 0% is steeper than 40%.
Figure 1. Share of the lot in each slope class (217 one-meter cells)[17].
A contour map can be added with the app’s “Capture view” (terrain mode).
3.4 Hazards
Table 4. Hazards checked
Hazard
What our data shows
4Zoning and approvals
The lot is zoned LNC (Local Neighborhood Commercial)[1]. The rules below are transcribed from the Pittsburgh Zoning Code[2]; transcription confidence: confirmed. Note: Rear setback is 20 ft, or none when the lot abuts a way. Site Plan Review applies on lots of 2,400 sf or more (§922.04.A.1). In LNC the sustainable-development FAR/height bonus (up to +20%) needs a Planning Commission PDP (§915.04.E). Ch. 916 applies.
Table 6. Allowed uses in LNC
Use
Code
What it means
One house (single-unit detached)
P
Allowed by right
Townhouse on its own lot (single-unit attached)
—
Not in our rules table
Two homes (two-unit)
P
Allowed by right
Three homes (three-unit)
P
Allowed by right
Four or more (multi-unit)
P
Allowed by right
Table 7. Dimensional rules: required vs. the studied scheme[2, 3]
Rule
Required
Scheme
Meets?
Minimum lot size
0 sq ft
2,337 sq ft
Yes
Front setback
0 ft
Kept (inside buildable area); contextual setback may apply
Yes
Rear setback
20 ft
Kept (inside buildable area)
Yes
Side setback
0 ft
Kept (inside buildable area)
Yes
Maximum height
45 ft
35 ft
Yes
Maximum stories
3
3
Yes
Parking
1.0 per home (1 total)
1
Yes
Floor area ratio (FAR)
2.00 max
1.39
Yes
Lot coverage
90% max
46%
5Process and timeline
Our requirements engine checks 71 possible steps against this lot and project[33]: 13 required, 10 likely, 16 possible, 7 ask, 25 not needed. “Required” means a cited law or rule requires it here; “Likely” and “Possible” are strong or weaker signals; “Ask” means we need an answer from you.
Figure 3. Phases in order with the number of items in each[33]. Review times are not loaded yet, so no durations are drawn.
6Market analysis
Sales comparables
We use only valid arm’s-length sales of the same kind of property, nearest first. At least 5 are needed; if there are fewer, the search widens step by step[12]. We found 15 single family sales within 0.25 miles from 2021-11-23 to 2026-04-20. Median sale price $500,000; median $226 per sq ft of living area[12].
Search steps: 15 within 0.25 mi.
Comps search widened
No valid sales of "municipal government" property in the last 5 years; showing single-family sales as a reference.
7Development budget
Costs use the EaseScore.AI cost assumptions cost-assumptions.v0.1[6]: Good spec construction at $250 per finished sq ft[11], on 2,542 sq ft (site-fit layout (Single-family house): 3,240 sq ft gross, 2,542 sq ft finished (livable)[3]). Every line shows its source label; every value can be changed on the parcel page.
Table 19. Development budget (CAPEX)
Line
Amount
Basis and source
Land
Land (purchase price)
$2,000
Public land: price set by the agency. Likely from agency sales of vacant lots in California-Kirkbride (10 sales, 2019-04 to 2024-04): median $1.00 per sq ft × 2,340 sq ft = $2,340; the range runs from the 25th percentile of agency sales up to the private market (vacant-land sales in the City of Pittsburgh (372 sales, 2019-01 to 2026-08): median $4.19 per sq ft of lot × 2,340 sq ft = $9,805).. Public land: price set by the agency[14]
Hard costs
Construction (base, standard foundation)
$636,000
2,542 finished sq ft × $250/SF (Good spec). Pittsburgh builder published ranges[11, 6]
Soft costs
Architecture and engineering
$51,000
8.0% of hard cost. Assumption — editable[6]
Contingency
Contingency (flat)
$45,000
7.0% of hard cost. Assumption — editable[6]
Financing and holding
Construction loan interest
$18,000
loan × average share drawn × annual rate × construction months ÷ 12. Bank prime rate (FRED DPRIME) + assumption[37, 6]
Closing, permit and carrying costs
$30,000
building permit and fees $4,000; survey, title, legal and insurance $19,000; water and sewer permit, connection and meter fees $1,000; lender fees $6,000; property taxes while approving and building $0. Selling costs at sale are taken from the sale price (Section 9).
8Operations (if rented)
This section applies if the homes are rented. This study’s scenario is to sell; the rental view is shown for comparison.
Property taxes
Total tax rate: 26.35 mills, meaning $26.35 of tax per $1,000 of assessed value each year[39]. On today’s assessment of $2,500[14], that is $2,500 ÷ 1,000 × 26.35 = $66 a year. A new building will be reassessed higher; the new assessed value is not estimated.
Table 20. Tax rate by taxing body, tax year 2026[39]
Taxing body
Type
Mills
Allegheny County
county
6.43
City of Pittsburgh
municipality
9.67
Pittsburgh
school district
10.25
Total
26.35
Rent roll and operating costs
Table 21. Operating statement, from the finance engine[8]
Measure
How it is figured
Result
Rent if every unit is leased, yearly (GPR)
Σ units × monthly rent × 12
$21,000
Rent you won't collect (vacancy and credit loss)
GPR × vacancy share
$1,050
Realistic yearly income (EGI)
GPR − vacancy and credit loss + other income
$19,950
Property taxes, yearly
assessed value × total millage ÷ 1,000
$9,473
Insurance, yearly (incl. flood and mine subsidence)
Every measure below is computed by the finance engine[8] from the budget in Section 7 and the assumptions in Appendix C. Rows that still need an input (a market cap rate, a hold period, a discount rate) say what they need. The formula column is the math in plain words.
Sources and uses
Every dollar in and out during construction. Uses are the budget in Section 7. Sources assume a construction loan at 80% of cost[6]; the rest is the developer’s cash (equity). No grants are assumed unless entered.
Table 24. Sources and uses of funds
Uses
Amount
Share
Sources
Amount
Share
Land (purchase)
$2,000
0%
Construction loan
$605,525
78%
Hard costs (construction and site work)
$636,000
82%
Developer equity (cash in)
$174,475
22%
Soft costs (design, permits, legal, fees)
$75,000
10%
Contingency
$45,000
6%
Financing and holding (interest, lender fees, taxes while building)
$24,000
3%
Total uses
$780,000
100%
Total sources
$780,000
100%
At the assumed sale value the sales do not repay these sources: $142,000 short[36]. That is the amount a subsidy, a land write-down or a lower cost would have to cover (Section 10).
10Affordable scenario
Affordable mode is off for this study. The limits and designations below are shown for reference.
Census tract status: not a HUD Qualified Census Tract; not in a Difficult Development Area; not in an Opportunity Zone[43]. Qualified tracts can raise tax-credit funding for a project.
Table 26. Maximum monthly rent by income level (percent of area median income, AMI), Allegheny County[9]
Income level
Studio
1 BR
2 BR
3 BR
4 BR
30% AMI
$579
$621
$745
$861
$960
40% AMI
$773
$828
$994
$1,148
$1,281
50% AMI
$966
$1,035
$1,242
$1,435
$1,601
60% AMI
$1,159
$1,242
$1,491
$1,722
$1,921
70% AMI
$1,352
$1,449
$1,739
$2,009
$2,241
80% AMI
$1,546
$1,657
$1,988
$2,297
$2,562
For-sale gap at market prices
At today’s nearby sale prices this home is $142,000 short[6, 36]. That is roughly the subsidy or land write-down it would take to break even. For comparison, subsidy needed per affordable for-sale home is estimated at $200,000 to $300,000[44].
Rental funding gap: needs loan terms
The rental gap is the total development cost ($780,000, Section 7) minus what the restricted rents can support in a permanent loan and equity. It needs the lender’s minimum debt coverage, the permanent loan rate and term, and the equity you commit; none of these has a default.
Tax abatement scenario (illustrative)
Pennsylvania lets local taxing bodies phase in the added value from new construction (LERTA-style abatements). Program terms differ by taxing body and were not checked for this lot, so this is an illustration, not a program quote. Assumption, editable: 100% of the tax on the added value is abated for 10 years. The added value is the pro forma’s assumption (construction cost), taxed at 26.35 mills.
11Sensitivity and scenarios
Sensitivity shows which assumption moves the result most[8]. Conservative: construction cost +10%, sale price −10%, interest rate +1 point (Assumption — editable). Optimistic: the same moves the other way.[6]
Table 28. Sensitivity scenarios, not the estimate's range (built to sell)
Measure
Conservative
Base
Optimistic
Total development cost
$860,919
$781,182
$701,898
Profit
−$286,494
−$142,932
$177
Profit margin
−33.3%
−18.3%
0.0%
These scenarios are what-ifs that move construction cost, sale price and the interest rate together. The estimate's range shown on the parcel page comes from each input's documented range instead: total cost $680,000 to $910,000, profit margin −35.3% to −0.6% (likely −18.2%).
12Risks and mitigations
Red flags
Only three things are red flags: the FEMA floodway, no legal access, or an active contamination site on the parcel.
None found in our data.
Review required
No review items found in our data.
Zoning permission
No discretionary zoning approval is needed for the studied scheme.
Data gaps
Table 29. Missing inputs and what they affect
Missing
Effect on this study
How to close it
Local bids
Construction costs are published builder ranges and editable estimates, not quotes for this lot.
Get a contractor's estimate and enter it in the pro forma.
City review times
The timeline shows the order of steps but not their length.
Ask the City's zoning and permit offices for current review times.
Listing-level rent comps
Rents rely on a ZIP-level index and HUD Fair Market Rents only.
Survey current listings nearby.
Absorption and lease-up data
Months to sell or lease up are editable assumptions (Section 6), supported only by counts of nearby sales, not a market study.
Ask local brokers how long similar homes took to sell or lease.
Which water utility serves the lot
Fees assume Pittsburgh Water (PWSA); some City neighborhoods are served by Pennsylvania American Water.
Confirm the utility with a water and sewer availability letter.
Steep areas in the buildable area
The site-fit solver does not yet remove slopes over 25% from the buildable area, so it may place a building on steep ground.
Check the scheme against a topographic survey.
Surveyed lot lines and frontage
Lot lines and frontage come from GIS, not a survey.
Order a boundary survey.
13Conclusion and next steps
This study is decision support, not a recommendation to buy or build. It shows what public data and published rules say about this lot, and what is still unknown.
What must be true for this to work
Costs come down, or the value goes up, enough to close the gap in Section 10 (for example through a lower land price, a simpler design, or a subsidy).
A survey confirms the lot lines, frontage and buildable area.
First three actions
Get a local construction cost estimate for the studied scheme.
14Limiting conditions
This study rests on the assumptions and limits below. Read the results with them in mind.
What the analysis assumes
Public records are correct as published: lot lines, lot size, assessed values, zoning districts and overlays, and past Zoning Board decisions.
The building shape is a placeholder layout from our site-fit solver, not an architect’s design (Appendix C).
Costs, loan terms, selling costs, months to sell or lease, and the tax abatement are editable defaults, each with a source label (Appendix C).
Values come from recent recorded sales and rent indexes on the dates shown; markets change.
Zoning rules are read from a hand-transcribed table of the City code for LNC; the Zoning Administrator’s reading governs.
What was not inspected
No site visit, survey, title search, soil or geotechnical test, environmental assessment, or building inspection.
No check of utilities at the curb, easements, deed restrictions, or liens.
No appraisal and no contractor bid. No review of the seller’s price or terms.
No conversation with the City, the Zoning Board, neighbors or community groups.
Out of scope
The developer’s capacity and financial strength (experience, balance sheet, credit, ability to raise equity or carry the project) are out of scope. So are tax, legal and lender underwriting, and the award of any subsidy or tax credit.
Data vintages
Table 30. Data sources cited in Sections 1–13 and their dates
#
Source
Publisher
Data date
1
Zoning districts
City of Pittsburgh Department of City Planning
vintage not recorded in our database
2
Pittsburgh Zoning Code, Title Nine (transcribed rules table)
Numbered in the order first cited. “Vintage not recorded” means our database does not store the publisher’s data date yet.
[1] Zoning districts. City of Pittsburgh Department of City Planning. vintage not recorded in our database.
[2] Pittsburgh Zoning Code, Title Nine (transcribed rules table). City of Pittsburgh. code as transcribed Sept. 2026. Sections used: §904.02.C site development standards table; §911.02 Use Table; §914.02.A https://library.municode.com/pa/pittsburgh
[3] QuickFit site-fit solver (EaseScore.AI engine). EaseScore.AI. deterministic; same inputs give the same result. Building sizes and story ranges are editable placeholders, not standards. See Appendix B.
[4] Parcel boundaries (GIS). Allegheny County. vintage not recorded in our database. Lot outline, GIS lot area and the site plan (sheet EA-101).
[5] Ease Score (EaseScore.AI engine). EaseScore.AI. scoring config 0.2. Deterministic; weights and curves live in one versioned config file. Factor sources are listed in Appendix D.
[6] Cost assumptions cost-assumptions.v0.1 (EaseScore.AI). EaseScore.AI. effective 2026-09-26. Every default is editable and carries a source label: “Pittsburgh builder published ranges”, “Estimate — confirm with bids”, “Local project data (owner-provided)”, “Assumption — editable”. Full list in Appendix C.
[7] Zoning Board of Adjustment and City Council zoning decisions. City of Pittsburgh (collected by EaseScore.AI). decisions 2008-12-02 to 2026-08-28. Counts one row per requested item; granted = outcome "granted" or "partially granted"; denied = outcome "denied"; withdrawn, expired and pending items are not counted.
[8] Finance module (EaseScore.AI engine). EaseScore.AI. deterministic. Holds no prices, costs or rates of its own: every input comes from the cost assumptions, the database or the user; missing inputs stay missing.
[10] Street centerlines (opened and paper streets). Allegheny County; City of Pittsburgh. vintage not recorded in our database. Frontage = an opened street centerline within 20 m of the lot. Confirm on a survey.
Pittsburgh builder published per-square-foot construction ranges. Incline Homes (2026); Home Builder Digest survey of Pittsburgh builders; EcoCraft. Base cost above a standard foundation, including builder overhead and profit; excludes land, demolition, unusual site work and soft costs.
BMethods and formulas
Site and data methods
Slope. Slope is computed for each 1 m lidar cell inside the lot; shares are the fraction of cells above 15%, 25% and 40%[17].
Overlays. A hazard or zoning overlay’s share is the part of the lot’s area inside it.
Street frontage. A lot fronts a street when an opened street centerline is within 20 m; front edges are the lot edges nearest that street[10].
Sales comps. Valid arm's-length sales only (county sale code 0), price ≥ $1,000, same property use, nearest first; comps list shows up to 25. The search widens by distance and years until at least 5 are found[12].
Zoning decision rates. Granted ÷ (granted + denied), shown only when at least 5 requests were decided; partial grants, withdrawals and pending items are left out[7].
Requirements. Each item is REQUIRED only when a cited law or rule requires it for this lot and project; otherwise it is Likely, Possible, Ask, or Not needed, with the reason shown[33].
Site-fit solver (QuickFit)
The buildable area is the lot minus a setback strip along each edge, minus any area that must be removed (only the FEMA floodway today). Unit rectangles are packed along the frontage and made as deep as allowed. Each scheme is checked for use permission, height and stories, lot size and lot area per unit, parking, and floor area ratio and coverage when the district has them. The limiting rule is found by relaxing each rule in turn. Footprints are rectangles; one building per lot[3].
Finance formulas
Table 31. Formulas used by the finance engine[8]
Measure
Formula
Months to approval, including delay
approval months + approval delay months
Months to build, including delay
construction months + construction delay months
Months from purchase to finished building
approval period + construction period
Land / purchase price
purchase price
Construction cost before site lines
hard cost (entered as a total)
Site work, demolition, grouting, retaining walls
hardSiteLines.siteWork
CAssumptions used
Every value the study used, and every value it still needs. “Placeholder” means an editable starting point, not a standard.
Table 32. Site-fit building sizes (placeholders)[3]
Building type
Unit width
Unit depth
Stories
Floor to floor
Garage tried
Single-family detached
16–32 ft
24–40 ft
2–3
10 ft
Yes
Duplex (side by side)
16–24 ft
28–40 ft
2–3
10 ft
Yes
Townhouse row
16–26 ft
28–40 ft
2–3
10 ft
Yes
Other solver placeholders: livable share of floor area 85%; garage bay 10 × 20 ft; surface stall with drive 200 sq ft; 1 space per home when parking is chosen (never below the minimum).
Table 33. Pro forma inputs used (cost-assumptions.v0.1, effective 2026-09-26)
Input
Value used
Range
Source
Homes (units)
1
—
Site-fit scheme (QuickFit)[3]
Finished (livable) floor area
2,542 sq ft
—
Site-fit scheme (QuickFit) — Floor area × the solver's livable share (placeholder)[3]
Land price
$2,000
$0–$10,000
Public land: price set by the agency — Public land: price set by the agency. Likely from agency sales of vacant lots in California-Kirkbride (10 sales, 2019-04 to 2024-04): median $1.00 per sq ft × 2,340 sq ft = $2,340; the range runs from the 25th percentile of agency sales up to the private market (vacant-land sales in the City of Pittsburgh (372 sales, 2019-01 to 2026-08): median $4.19 per sq ft of lot × 2,340 sq ft = $9,805).[6]
Build quality
Good spec — Clean modern finishes, efficient plan
—
Pittsburgh builder published ranges[11]
Construction cost per finished sq ft (includes builder overhead and profit)
$250/SF
$225–$275/SF
Pittsburgh builder published ranges — Published per-square-foot ranges from Pittsburgh-area home builders (Incline Homes 2026; Home Builder Digest survey of Pittsburgh builders; EcoCraft).
DEase Score breakdown
The Ease Score (0–100) measures how hard it is to get housing built on this lot: rules, ground, hazards, access and process. Money is not in it; that is the separate “Pencils?” result. Score for new single-family house: 96 (Easy)[5]. Factors with evidence carry 100% of the weight. Scoring config 0.2.
Table 35. Factors (score = weighted average of factors with evidence)
Factor
Weight
Sub-score
Evidence
In plain words
F1 · Zoning permission
25
100
complete
A single-unit detached house is allowed by right in LNC (§911.02 Use Table); it fits the setbacks and lot rules as drawn.
F2 · Terrain / buildable ground
20
100
complete
0% of the lot is steeper than 25%.
F3 · Geohazards
15
95
partial
Combined-sewer area (basement backup risk).
F4 · Access & infrastructure
15
90
partial
Fronts an opened street; water/sewer service not confirmed (scored as unknown); frequent transit 41 m away.
F5 · Approval burden & time
15
100
complete
No approvals beyond a building permit.
F6 · Lot & acquisition readiness
5
90
complete
Vacant lot; publicly owned (City of Pittsburgh; city / land bank path).
F7 · Market activity
5
68
complete
86 valid sales and 143 completed building permits within 1/2 mile in 3 years: busier than 68% of City parcels.
Table 36. Score by building strategy
Strategy
Score
Band
New single-family house
96
Easy
Duplex
91
Easy
3-4 unit building
89
Easy
Townhouse row
93
Easy
ELimitations
What this study is and is not
It is a screening study built from public data and published rules, computed the same way every time. It is not an appraisal, a zoning determination, a survey, an environmental assessment, or engineering, legal or financial advice. Verify every item with the permitting office, a surveyor, an engineer, your lender and your accountant.
Who this helps and who it could hurt
It helps homeowners, small builders, nonprofits and planners see the rules, hazards and costs of a lot early, before paying a consultant. It could hurt people in these ways, and this is what the tool does today:
Buying on an estimate. A lot that “fits” here may not fit after a survey or engineer looks. Scores and costs show ranges, each number cites its source, and this study lists its data gaps.
Targeting owners behind on taxes. No owner names are stored or shown. The Planner’s tax-delinquent filter is off by default but not limited to public land. There is no “motivated seller” feature.
Displacement where rents are rising. The Policy and Nonprofit seats show rent burden as context. It is never used to compute the Ease Score.
Thin data. Areas with less data get wider ranges or a “Preliminary — insufficient evidence” score instead of one number, which can steer attention by data quality rather than need.
Older homes. Buildings that would not meet today’s code point to the rule, not the house. This study does not rule on whether any home is legal to keep.
More at easescore.ai/limitations#who-it-helps.
What the tool can get wrong
GIS lot lines, street frontage and building footprints can be off by several feet, which matters on small lots.
The site-fit solver uses rectangular footprints and placeholder sizes, and does not yet remove steep ground from the buildable area.
Zoning rules were transcribed by hand; overlays, compatibility standards and some exceptions are not modeled.
Mine maps are incomplete; the absence of a mapped mine does not prove there is none.
Rents are asking rents, property taxes after building are estimates (the County sets them), and permit times are City targets, not guaranteed.
Sales comps are mostly older homes, so they are a reference for new construction, not a price.
Past zoning decisions describe history, not the outcome of any future case.
Data gaps for this parcel
Local bids: Construction costs are published builder ranges and editable estimates, not quotes for this lot.
City review times: The timeline shows the order of steps but not their length.
Listing-level rent comps: Rents rely on a ZIP-level index and HUD Fair Market Rents only.
FGlossary
AMI (area median income)
The middle household income for the region. Affordable rents are set as a percent of it.
By right
Allowed without a public hearing, as long as the project meets the written rules.
CAPEX
The one-time money to buy the land and build.
Cap rate
A property’s yearly net income divided by its value. Buyers use it to price rentals.
Combined sewer
Old pipes that carry both rainwater and sewage. In heavy rain they can back up.
Comps (comparable sales)
Recent sales of similar nearby homes, used as a price reference.
Conditional use
A use that needs Planning Commission review and City Council approval.
Contingency
Money set aside for surprises during construction.
DSCR (debt service coverage ratio)
Yearly net income divided by yearly loan payments. Lenders want it above about 1.2.
Equity
The cash the owner puts in, as opposed to the loan.
FAR (floor area ratio)
Total floor area divided by lot area.
Floodway
The channel of a river or stream and the land next to it that must stay open to carry floodwater.
Geotechnical report
An engineer’s study of the soil and rock, used to design foundations and walls.
Hard costs
The cost of physical construction: labor and materials.
IRR (internal rate of return)
The yearly return a project earns over its life, counting when money goes in and comes out.
LIHTC
Low-Income Housing Tax Credits: federal credits that raise equity for affordable housing.
Mill (millage)
Property tax rate: one mill is $1 of tax per $1,000 of assessed value.
NOI (net operating income)
Rent collected minus the costs of running the building, before loan payments.
Numbers in brackets, like [3], point to the numbered source list in Appendix A, which gives each source’s publisher and data date. Amber boxes are items that need review; red boxes are red flags (only three things count: floodway, no legal access, or a contamination site on the lot). Dashed gray boxes mark results that cannot be computed yet, with the reason. Words in the glossary (Appendix F) are explained in plain English.
$790,000
$890,000
$790,000
Value or income
$690,000 in sales
$25,600 a year after running costs
$6,664 a year after running costs
Profit or gap
$152,000 gap
2.9% yield on cost
0.8% yield on cost
Margin or yield
-19.2% margin
2.9% a year
0.8% a year
Pencils?
Does not pencil
Depends on the loan and a local cap rate
Depends on the loan and a local cap rate
Can you build here?
Yes, on paper. A single-family house with 1 unit fits by right under LNC zoning[1, 2], based on our site-fit check[3].
Does it pencil?
No: it costs about $780,000 and would net about $640,000 after selling costs, $142,000 short.[6, 8]
Cost: land $2,000 + construction $636,000 + design and engineering $51,000 + contingency $45,000 + loan interest $18,000 + closing, permit and carrying costs $30,000 = $780,000 total.
Value: $271/SF × 2,542 sq ft = $689,458 per home, rounded to $690,000; × 1 home = $690,000 in sales.
Profit: $690,000 sales − $780,000 total cost − $52,000 selling costs = $142,000 short (a loss of 18.2% of cost).
What’s in the way?
No red flags or review items were found in our data. Data gaps are listed in Section 12.
What next?
Get a builder's bid for this layout before buying; the cost lines show what drives the total.[6]
Routine transaction and permit items are in the full checklist (Section 5).
Ease Score · New single-family house
96 · Easy[5]
How easy it is to get housing built here, 0–100 · config 0.2
Pencils?
No · −18.2%[6]
Profit ÷ total cost. Shown separately from the Ease Score.
Months to permit
about 1[5]
Estimate from typical approval steps, not permit records
Assumptions that matter most
The building shape comes from our site-fit solver using editable placeholder sizes (Appendix C), not an architect’s design[3].
Lot lines and street frontage come from county GIS, not a survey[4, 10].
Construction is priced at $250 per finished sq ft (Good spec), from published Pittsburgh builder ranges[11]; site adders, soft costs, contingency and loan terms are editable defaults, each with a source label (Appendix C)[6]. Items with no local cost yet are listed as not included, never counted as zero.
Market values are references from past sales and rent indexes, not a price opinion[12, 13].
Landslide-prone (City overlay)
Not in the overlay[18]. Mapped slope-movement areas (1982 inventory) within 300 ft: 0[19]
Undermined / mines
Not in the City’s undermined overlay[20]. Mine subsidence insurance risk: not mapped; nearest mapped mined-out area not found; mine map sheet WPA_Carnegie_Sht_3_PGH[21]. Mine maps are incomplete; absence of a mapped mine is not proof that no mine exists.
Flooding
Floodway 0%, 100-year zone 0%, 500-year zone 0% of the lot[22]. In this census tract: 32 flood insurance policies and 0 claims in 10 years, median premium $1,143[23]; 61 flooding complaints to 311 in 5 years[24].
Sewer backup
In a combined sewer area (storm and sewage share pipes), where basement backups are more common in heavy rain[25].
Contamination
0 cleanup records on the lot and 0 within 50 ft[26]; 0 within 500 ft[26].
Streams and wetlands
None within 100 ft[27].
3.5 Access, utilities, transit and schools
Table 5. Access and services
Street access
Fronts an opened street[10]
Water and sewer
Assumed Pittsburgh Water (PWSA); confirm with an availability letter. Combined sewer area. At sale: conditional: PWSA dye test before sale only in separate sanitary sewer areas (Evidence of Compliance application decides); valid 3 yrs; no CCTV.[28]
Transit
Nearest stop 41 m; nearest frequent stop 41 m; 31 frequent stops within 800 m (about half a mile)[29]
Schools
City of Pittsburgh school district; Pittsburgh Public Schools feeder: Manchester Pk-8 (elementary), Manchester Pk-8 (middle), North Side (high)[30]
Street trees within 15 m
0[15]
Figure 2. Site plan, sheet EA-101 (screening drawing from public data, not a survey)[4, 2, 3, 31, 10, 17, 32]. Street curb, walk and right-of-way widths are typical-width assumptions, not surveyed.
Yes
Best options for this lot (ease and money kept separate; the easiest option that pencils first)
#
Option
Ease Score
Zoning path
Pencils?
1
New single-family · Needs subsidy or lower costs
96 (Easy)
Allowed
Doesn't pencil
2
Townhouse row
93 (Easy)
Zoning not in our data: confirm with the municipality
Can't tell yet
3
Duplex
91 (Easy)
Allowed use; needs a variance (parking per unit)
Doesn't pencil
4
3–4 units
89 (Easy)
Allowed use; needs a variance (parking per unit)
Can't tell yet
5
ADU (backyard unit)
—
No existing building on the lot.
—
6
Renovate existing
—
No existing building on the lot.
—
Street precedent
Brighton Rd (this stretch of the street, 400 ft each way on the same side): 4 buildings on this block; most sit 0–38 ft from the front lot line. The district has no minimum front setback. Medians over 4 measured buildings (12 lots): lot 24 ft wide, 3 stories.
Contextual front setback: The district has no minimum front setback, so there is nothing to relieve. 1 of 4 existing buildings here would not meet today's code.
Measured from Allegheny County building footprints and parcel lines (approximate; an applicant documents neighbors' setbacks with a survey).
Approvals needed
None for zoning: the studied scheme is allowed by right[3]. Building, grading and other permits are in Section 5.
Past zoning decisions in LNC districts
Table 8. Decided requests in LNC (granted or denied only)[7]
Kind of request
Decided
Granted
Denied
Grant rate
Years
Dimensional variance
29
26
3
90%
2025–2026
Special exception
12
11
1
92%
2025–2026
Use variance
4
4
0
Too few (<5)
2025–2025
Other relief
2
2
0
Too few (<5)
2025–2025
Conditional use
2
1
1
Too few (<5)
2008–2008
A rate is shown only when at least 5 requests were decided. Past results do not predict a single case.
What would unlock more homes
We re-ran the site-fit solver with one rule relaxed at a time. These are policy what-ifs, not requests you can make[3].
Table 9. One rule relaxed at a time
What if
Rule now
Extra homes
Extra floor area
No parking minimum
—
0
0
No minimum lot size
0
0
0
No minimum lot area per unit
—
0
0
Predicted time to a permit: about 0.7 months
This is an estimate built from the approval steps this project needs, not from permit records for similar projects.[5] How it adds up:
building permit: City target 21 calendar days per review round (City target, not measured)
Construction time is not estimated. Ask the City’s zoning and permit offices for current review times.
Pittsburgh-specific items for this lot
PossibleSewer lateral inspection / replacement at sale. Pittsburgh City: sewer lateral test required at sale. conditional: PWSA dye test before sale only in separate sanitary sewer areas (Evidence of Compliance application decides); valid 3 yrs; no CCTV[33]
PossibleContextual setback determination. LNC lets the front setback follow neighboring buildings (§925.06). Useful when the 0 ft standard doesn't fit; comparing neighbors needs building footprints (loading).[33]
PossibleRegistered Community Organization meeting. Required only if the project needs a public hearing (variance, special exception, conditional use) and meets a size/type trigger. RCO here: the Registered Community Organization for this area.[33]
LikelySewer/water tap-in & connection fees. New 1 unit(s) or connections: tap and capacity fees can run thousands per unit (authority tariff table loading).[33]
PA Dept. of Revenue; municipality; school district
5% of the price, due at purchase and again at sale (Commonwealth of Pennsylvania 1% + Pittsburgh City 3% + Pittsburgh School District (in Pittsburgh City) 1%).
72 P.S. §8101-C et seq. (state 1%); local rates per Allegheny County
Required
Survey (boundary)
Licensed surveyor
Setbacks, permits, and lenders all rely on the true lot lines.
—
Required
Title search & title insurance
Title company
Every purchase needs clear title before closing.
—
Likely
Utility availability letters
Each utility
Vacant lot: confirm water, sewer, gas, and electric can serve it.
—
Possible
Lead water service line
Water authority (PWSA in the city)
Service-line data isn't loaded yet.
—
Possible
Phase I Environmental Site Assessment
Environmental consultant
No trigger found in our data; a lender may still require one.
ASTM E1527-21
Possible
Phase II Environmental Site Assessment
Environmental consultant
Only if the Phase I finds a recognized environmental condition.
—
Possible
Sewer lateral inspection / replacement at sale
Municipality / sewer authority
Pittsburgh City: sewer lateral test required at sale. conditional: PWSA dye test before sale only in separate sanitary sewer areas (Evidence of Compliance application decides); valid 3 yrs; no CCTV
—
Possible
Survey (topographic)
Licensed surveyor
New construction usually needs spot elevations for drainage design.
—
Possible
Tax abatement / incentive application
City / County / school district
Check City of Pittsburgh (e.g. LERTA) programs.
—
Ask
Appraisal
Lender
Will the project be financed?
—
Ask
Construction loan
Lender
Will the project be financed?
—
Not needed here: Access problems (steps-only, paper street, landlocked); Back taxes, liens & municipal claims; Flood insurance; Floodplain review & elevation certificate; Mine subsidence — investigation, insurance, or grouting; Point-of-sale / occupancy inspection; Radon test & mitigation; Retaining wall failure / hillside repair; Underground oil tank; Wetland / stream delineation.
Design & engineering
Table 11. Design & engineering items[33]
Status
Item
Why
Rule
Required
Architectural drawings
Architect / designer
Permits need drawings; sealed drawings above certain scope (confirm threshold).
—
Required
Energy code compliance
Designer; reviewed at permit
New conditioned space.
PA UCC (34 Pa. Code Ch. 403) — IECC as adopted
Possible
Civil site plan
Civil engineer
Depends on grading and site work.
—
Possible
Structural engineer
Structural engineer
Depends on the design.
—
Possible
Utility upgrades (electric service, transformer)
Duquesne Light / utility
Depends on the electrical load.
—
Not needed here: Accessibility design (Fair Housing Act / code); Fire alarm / sprinkler design and permit; Geotechnical report; Mine subsidence investigation & insurance; Retaining wall design.
Zoning
Table 12. Zoning items[33]
Status
Item
Why
Rule
Required
Parking & loading compliance
Zoning review
Off-street parking required. LNC minimum: 1 space(s) per unit → 1 for 1 unit(s).
Zoned LNC. New buildings, additions, and changes of use need zoning approval.
—
Possible
Contextual setback determination
Zoning Administrator
LNC lets the front setback follow neighboring buildings (§925.06). Useful when the 0 ft standard doesn't fit; comparing neighbors needs building footprints (loading).
Pittsburgh Zoning Code §925.06
Possible
Paper street vacation
DOMI right-of-way vacation
Unopened-street data isn't loaded yet.
—
Possible
Registered Community Organization meeting
City Planning / RCO
Required only if the project needs a public hearing (variance, special exception, conditional use) and meets a size/type trigger. RCO here: the Registered Community Organization for this area.
Pittsburgh Code §178E.08(c)
Ask
Lot consolidation / subdivision / lot line adjustment
Planning Commission / municipality
Will you combine or split lots?
—
Not needed here: Certificate of Appropriateness (historic); Conditional use approval; Historic review delays; Inclusionary zoning compliance; Special exception; Variance.
Permits
Table 13. Permits items[33]
Status
Item
Why
Rule
Required
Building permit
PLI (Pittsburgh) / municipal building official
Construction work.
PA UCC (34 Pa. Code Ch. 403)
Likely
Electrical permit
PLI / inspection agency
New or altered wiring.
—
Likely
Mechanical (HVAC) permit
PLI / municipality
New or replaced heating/cooling.
—
Likely
Plumbing permit
Allegheny County Health Dept
New or altered plumbing.
ACHD Article XV (Plumbing) — confirm
Likely
Sewer/water tap-in & connection fees
Water / sewer authority
New 1 unit(s) or connections: tap and capacity fees can run thousands per unit (authority tariff table loading).
—
Likely
Stormwater management plan
Water & sewer authority / municipality
New roof and paving add impervious area (threshold pending).
—
Likely
Street opening permit
DOMI
Vacant lot: new water/sewer connections are usually dug in the street.
—
Possible
Grading / earth disturbance permit
PLI / municipality
Depends on cut/fill volume (threshold pending).
—
Possible
Sewage planning (new connections/lots)
Municipality / sewer authority; PA DEP
New units or lots add sewer load; confirm the local planning rule.
PA Sewage Facilities Act (Act 537), 35 P.S. §750.1 et seq.
Ask
Curb cut / driveway permit
DOMI
Will you add or change a driveway?
—
Ask
Erosion & sediment control plan
Allegheny County Conservation District; PA DEP
Roughly how much ground will be disturbed (sq ft)?
25 Pa. Code Ch. 102
Not needed here: Asbestos survey + Health Dept notification; Demolition permit; Utility disconnects.
Construction
Table 14. Construction items[33]
Status
Item
Why
Rule
Required
Builder's risk insurance
Insurer
Construction in progress.
—
Required
Contractor licensing / registration
City; PA Attorney General (HICPA)
City contractor license plus state home-improvement registration for residential work.
Home Improvement Consumer Protection Act, 73 P.S. §517.1 et seq.
Required
Dumpster (container count)
Hauler
Debris removal.
—
Likely
Dumpster / container permit in street
DOMI
Small lot (2,337 sq ft) leaves little room to stage a container.
—
Likely
Portable toilet / site facilities
Vendor
Crews on site.
—
Possible
Sidewalk repair / replacement
DOMI / owner
Depends on sidewalk condition at inspection.
—
Possible
Tree removal / street tree permit
City forestry
No City street trees mapped within 15 m (inventory may be incomplete).
—
Ask
Neighbor / party wall agreement
Owner & neighbor (attorney)
Is it a rowhouse or does work touch a shared wall?
—
Ask
Road / lane / sidewalk closure permit
DOMI
Will work, deliveries, or containers block the street or sidewalk?
—
Not needed here: Lead-safe work practices.
Closeout
Table 15. Closeout items[33]
Status
Item
Why
Rule
Required
Certificate of Occupancy
PLI / municipality
New units or change of use.
—
Required
Property tax jump after construction
Allegheny County Office of Property Assessments
New construction is reassessed the year after completion (a prorated interim bill is possible). Today: 26.35 mills × $2,500 assessed = about $66/yr. Every $100,000 of added assessed value adds about $2,635/yr.
—
Likely
As-built survey
Surveyor
New construction.
—
Figure 4. Price per sq ft of the 15 nearest comparable sales by sale date; dashed line = median of all 15[12].
Table 16. Nearest comparable sales (up to 15 shown)[12]
Address
Sale date
Price
Living area
$ / sq ft
Distance
1521 Buena Vista St
2024-12-04
$785,000
3,180
$247
0.06 mi
1532 Marquis Way
2025-12-26
$205,000
1,939
$106
0.08 mi
1521 Wolpert Way
2024-06-08
$325,000
1,440
$226
0.09 mi
1414 Buena Vista St
2022-03-17
$285,000
3,124
$91
0.10 mi
1414 Buena Vista St
2023-04-28
$700,000
3,124
$224
0.10 mi
1726 Brighton Rd
2022-09-29
$105,000
1,720
$61
0.13 mi
612 N Taylor Ave
2025-12-18
$1,025,000
3,280
$313
0.13 mi
605 W Jefferson St
2022-06-27
$600,000
1,770
$339
0.14 mi
605 W Jefferson St
2026-04-20
$650,000
1,770
$367
0.14 mi
526 Armandale St
2025-07-28
$500,000
1,936
$258
0.15 mi
520 Jacksonia St
2024-09-12
$525,000
2,400
$219
0.16 mi
1236 Monterey St
2021-11-23
$405,000
2,028
$200
0.19 mi
1239 Resaca Pl
2024-07-29
$500,000
1,020
$490
0.21 mi
416 N Taylor Ave
2024-12-06
$405,000
2,105
$192
0.23 mi
1236 Resaca Pl
2022-05-20
$355,000
896
$396
0.24 mi
Rents
The Zillow rent index for ZIP 15212 was $1,488 a month in 2026-08, up 4.1% from a year earlier ($1,430)[13]. This covers all home types in the ZIP, not new construction.
Table 18. Rent by bedroom count (monthly, rounded to $50)
Home
Likely
Range
Basis
HUD FMR
1 bedroom
$1,100
$1,000–$1,250
HUD Small Area Fair Market Rent FY2026, ZIP 15212 (benchmark, not listings)[34] Rent data temporarily unavailable (RentCast listings could not be reached or the monthly quota is used up).
$1,120
2 bedrooms
$1,350
$1,200–$1,500
HUD Small Area Fair Market Rent FY2026, ZIP 15212 (benchmark, not listings)[34] Rent data temporarily unavailable (RentCast listings could not be reached or the monthly quota is used up).
$1,350
3 bedrooms
$1,750
$1,550–$1,900
HUD Small Area Fair Market Rent FY2026, ZIP 15212 (benchmark, not listings)[34] Rent data temporarily unavailable (RentCast listings could not be reached or the monthly quota is used up).
$1,730
Fallback: likely = the benchmark; range = ±10% around it (an assumption, not a market range). All rounded to the nearest $50. Same bedrooms (1-bedroom); listed or seen in the last 6 months (183 days); size within ±35% of 700 sq ft when the size is known; radius starts at 0.5 mi and widens (0.5, 1, 1.5, 2, 3 mi) until at least 5 listings. Asking rents often run above signed leases; no new-construction premium assumed unless the data shows one.
Market activity
In the last 3 years within half a mile: 86 valid sales and 143 completed building permits. That is more activity than about 68% of City parcels in our fixed sample of 1,420[35].
Absorption and lease-up
Support from comps: 11 new-construction home sales within 2 mi over the last 3 years, about 3.7 a year[36]. Nearby valid sales of the comparable use: 15 within 0.25 mi over about 5.0 years, about 3.0 a year[12].
Assumption, editable: finished homes sell within 3 months after completion, and a rental leases up within 3 months[6]. The for-sale case uses the months-to-sell assumption. This is not a market study; a local broker should confirm the pace.
[6, 38, 39]
Total development cost (TDC)
$780,000
land + hard + soft + contingency + financing[8]
Cost per home / per finished sq ft
$781,182
$307 per finished sq ft
Cost: land $2,000 + construction $636,000 + design and engineering $51,000 + contingency $45,000 + loan interest $18,000 + closing, permit and carrying costs $30,000 = $780,000 total.
Sanity check. Your estimate: $781,182 per home. Recent Allegheny County projects: $300,000 to $594,000 per home (6 projects, mostly new multifamily and affordable; all-in cost).[40] National reference: $162 per sq ft for construction only (national reference, not a Pittsburgh default)[41].
Realty transfer tax is 5.0% of the price[42]; the seller’s customary half is counted in selling costs (Section 9). The buyer’s half at purchase is not in the total above.
$13,569
Income after running costs (NOI)
EGI − OPEX
$6,381
Rent used: $1,750 a month per home (3-bedroom home: HUD Small Area Fair Market Rent FY2026, ZIP 15212 (benchmark, not listings))[34]. Vacancy, maintenance, management, insurance and reserves are editable assumptions (Appendix C)[6]; the tax uses the actual millage on an assumed new assessed value (county land value + construction cost)[39].
Figure 5. Capital stack: uses of funds (left) and sources of funds (right), same total.
If built to sell
Size: 1 home × 2,542 sq ft finished. Site-fit layout (Single-family house): 3,240 sq ft gross, 2,542 sq ft finished (livable).
New-construction comps: 11 sales within 2 mi, median $630,000, $271 per sq ft, median size 2,322 sq ft, built 2015–2025, sold 2023-12-13 to 2026-05-21[36]. Search: 1 within 0.25 mi → 3 within 0.5 mi → 4 within 1 mi → 21 within 2 mi. Search widened to 2 mi (1 within 0.25 mi; 3 within 0.5 mi; 4 within 1 mi; 21 within 2 mi).
Older homes nearby sold for a median $226 per sq ft (15 sales within 0.25 mi). That is a floor, not the value of a new home.[12]
Table 25. New-construction sales used (nearest first)
Sold
Price
Sq ft
$/sq ft
Built
Miles
2026-04-20
$650,000
1,770
$367
2016
0.14
2024-06-04
$479,000
2,451
$195
2022
0.33
2024-03-11
$680,000
2,322
$293
2015
0.42
2025-08-06
$650,000
2,154
$302
2017
0.89
2025-07-09
$660,000
2,586
$255
2021
1.29
2025-04-10
$635,000
2,486
$255
2021
1.30
2026-05-21
$630,000
1,970
$320
2025
1.31
2026-04-17
$630,000
1,970
$320
2025
1.31
2025-08-27
$575,000
2,120
$271
2021
1.46
2023-12-13
$630,000
2,330
$270
2015
1.46
2024-06-14
$629,900
2,436
$259
2015
1.48
Sale value: $271 per finished sq ft (median of 11 new-construction sales within 2 mi, 2023-12-13 to 2026-05-21[36]) × 2,544 finished sq ft = $690,000. Selling costs: broker and closing 5% plus the seller’s half of the transfer tax[6, 42].
Value: $271/SF × 2,542 sq ft = $689,458 per home, rounded to $690,000; × 1 home = $690,000 in sales.
Profit: $690,000 sales − $780,000 total cost − $52,000 selling costs = $142,000 short (a loss of 18.2% of cost).
Lenders commonly look for income of at least about 1.2 times the loan payments (DSCR). That is a rule of thumb, not a quote.
[6]
[39]
Table 27. Effect of the abatement
Added assessed value (assumed)
$356,990
Yearly tax on the added value
$9,407
Tax abated each year
$9,407
Tax abated over 10 years (not discounted)
$94,067
Rental: income after running costs (NOI), without → with
$6,000 → $15,407
Rental: yield on cost, without → with
0.8% → 2.0%
Built to sell, the abatement goes to the buyer as lower taxes; it does not change the builder’s cost or profit in this study, and any effect on the sale price is not assumed. Change the share and years with the report settings pf_abate_pct and pf_abate_years. Tax abatement on the new construction value (LERTA-style, illustrative).
Public cost and public benefit
Public cost: a subsidy or land write-down of about $142,000 to break even at today’s sale prices ($142,000 per home)[6, 36], plus $94,067 of property tax forgone if the illustrative abatement above is used. Public benefit: 1 new home, and about $9,407 a year in new property tax once any abatement ends[39]. This is a brief screen, not a fiscal impact study: it leaves out services the homes use, school costs, and wider effects on the neighborhood.
Possible sources to close a gap
Low-Income Housing Tax Credits (LIHTC): federal credits sold to investors for equity; awarded by PHFA through a competitive round.
HOME and CDBG: federal block grants passed through the City or County, often as soft loans.
PHARE: the state’s housing trust fund, administered by PHFA.
Housing Opportunity Fund: the City of Pittsburgh’s housing trust fund, administered by the Urban Redevelopment Authority.
Tax abatements: local programs that phase in the new assessed value; eligibility varies.
Program names are listed for awareness; no award amounts are assumed.
Figure 6. Which assumption matters most: profit when each assumption is moved down (light) and up (dark), one at a time, largest swing first[6].
Break-even points
Construction costs would have to fall by 18.5% for the project to break even.
It breaks even if sale prices come in 22.4% above the comps (about $332 per sq ft).
Cost of approval delays
Every month of delay adds holding costs: taxes, insurance and loan interest. Taxes alone on today’s assessment are about $5 a month ($2,500 × 26.35 ÷ 1,000 ÷ 12)[14, 39]. In this model a 6-month approval delay changes profit by −$33[8].
effective 2026-09-26
7
Zoning Board of Adjustment and City Council zoning decisions
City of Pittsburgh (collected by EaseScore.AI)
decisions 2008-12-02 to 2026-08-28
8
Finance module (EaseScore.AI engine)
EaseScore.AI
deterministic
9
LIHTC rent and income limits (Allegheny County)
Pennsylvania Housing Finance Agency
2026
10
Street centerlines (opened and paper streets)
Allegheny County; City of Pittsburgh
vintage not recorded in our database
11
Pittsburgh builder published per-square-foot construction ranges
Incline Homes (2026); Home Builder Digest survey of Pittsburgh builders; EcoCraft
2026 publications
12
Property sale transactions (valid arm's-length sales)
Allegheny County Department of Real Estate
sales through 2026-04-20
13
Zillow Observed Rent Index (ZORI), all homes, smoothed
Zillow Research
latest month 2026-08-31
14
Property Assessments
Allegheny County Office of Property Assessments
as of 2026-09-01
15
Neighborhoods, City-owned property, tax liens, street trees
City of Pittsburgh; Allegheny County
vintage not recorded in our database
16
American Community Survey 5-year estimates (census tract)
US Census Bureau
ACS 2024
17
1 m lidar elevation model (PA Western 2019), slope computed by EaseScore
USGS 3D Elevation Program
2019 lidar collection
18
Landslide-prone areas (§906.04 overlay)
City of Pittsburgh
vintage not recorded in our database
19
Landslide inventory (recorded slides)
Allegheny County / University of Pittsburgh
vintage not recorded in our database
20
Undermined areas (§906.05 overlay)
City of Pittsburgh
vintage not recorded in our database
21
Mine maps and mined-out areas; Mine Subsidence Insurance risk map
PA DEP; PA Mine Map Atlas (PASDA)
vintage not recorded in our database
22
National Flood Hazard Layer
FEMA
vintage not recorded in our database
23
NFIP redacted policies and claims, aggregated by census tract
OpenFEMA
vintage not recorded in our database
24
311 flooding requests (5 years), by census tract
City of Pittsburgh 311
vintage not recorded in our database
25
Combined sewersheds
PWSA / 3 Rivers Wet Weather
vintage not recorded in our database
26
Land Recycling Program sites; ACRES brownfields
PA DEP; US EPA
vintage not recorded in our database
27
Streams (National Hydrography Dataset) and wetlands (National Wetlands Inventory)
USGS; US Fish and Wildlife Service
vintage not recorded in our database
28
Point-of-sale and sewer-lateral rules at sale
Municipality / water authority
vintage not recorded in our database
29
Transit schedule (GTFS), weekday 7–9 am service
Pittsburgh Regional Transit
vintage not recorded in our database
30
School district and Pittsburgh Public Schools feeder boundaries
Allegheny County; Pittsburgh Public Schools
vintage not recorded in our database
31
Building footprints
Allegheny County
vintage not recorded in our database
32
Zoning overlays and Registered Community Organizations
City of Pittsburgh
vintage not recorded in our database
33
Requirements catalog and rules (EaseScore.AI engine)
EaseScore.AI, from the Pittsburgh Code and agency handouts
catalog as of Sept. 2026
34
Fair Market Rents (small area (ZIP))
US Department of Housing and Urban Development
FY 2026
35
Market activity: valid sales and completed building permits within ½ mile, 3 years
Allegheny County sales; City of Pittsburgh PLI permits
computed 2026-09-27
36
Valid sales of new construction (homes built no more than 10 years before the sale)
Allegheny County Department of Real Estate sales; Office of Property Assessments (year built, living area)
sales through 2026-05-21
37
Bank Prime Loan Rate (DPRIME)
Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, via FRED
observation 2026-09-21
38
Residential building permit base fee: $6.00 per $1,000 of construction value
City of Pittsburgh Permits, Licenses and Inspections (reported)
effective 2026-01-01
39
Real estate millage rates (county, municipality, school district)
Allegheny County Treasurer
tax year 2026
40
Recent Allegheny County housing project costs (total development cost per home)
WESA; NEXTpittsburgh; PublicSource (news reports)
as reported, 2025–2026
41
Cost of Constructing a Home 2024
National Association of Home Builders
2024
42
Realty transfer tax rates
PA Department of Revenue; local taxing bodies
vintage not recorded in our database
43
Qualified Census Tracts and Difficult Development Areas; Opportunity Zones
HUD; CDFI Fund
vintage not recorded in our database
44
Subsidy needed per affordable for-sale home
Main + Elm (ELDI partner) estimate
vintage not recorded in our database
Study generated September 27, 2026. Results can change when any source is updated.
[11]
2026 publications.
[12] Property sale transactions (valid arm's-length sales). Allegheny County Department of Real Estate. sales through 2026-04-20. Valid arm's-length sales only (county sale code 0), price ≥ $1,000, same property use, nearest first; comps list shows up to 25 https://data.wprdc.org/dataset/real-estate-sales
[14] Property Assessments. Allegheny County Office of Property Assessments. as of 2026-09-01. Address, lot size, use, assessed values, year built, condition, owner category (never names). https://data.wprdc.org/dataset/property-assessments
[15] Neighborhoods, City-owned property, tax liens, street trees. City of Pittsburgh; Allegheny County. vintage not recorded in our database.
[17] 1 m lidar elevation model (PA Western 2019), slope computed by EaseScore. USGS 3D Elevation Program. 2019 lidar collection. Slope per 1 m cell inside the lot; shares are of the lot's cells. https://www.usgs.gov/3d-elevation-program
[18] Landslide-prone areas (§906.04 overlay). City of Pittsburgh. vintage not recorded in our database.
[19] Landslide inventory (recorded slides). Allegheny County / University of Pittsburgh. vintage not recorded in our database.
[20] Undermined areas (§906.05 overlay). City of Pittsburgh. vintage not recorded in our database.
[21] Mine maps and mined-out areas; Mine Subsidence Insurance risk map. PA DEP; PA Mine Map Atlas (PASDA). vintage not recorded in our database. Mine maps are incomplete; the absence of a mapped mine does not prove there is none. https://www.minemaps.psu.edu/?LocalSheetID=WPA_Carnegie_Sht_3_PGH
[25] Combined sewersheds. PWSA / 3 Rivers Wet Weather. vintage not recorded in our database.
[26] Land Recycling Program sites; ACRES brownfields. PA DEP; US EPA. vintage not recorded in our database. Site points on the lot, or within 50 ft of it. EPA ACRES records carry no status and count as active.
[27] Streams (National Hydrography Dataset) and wetlands (National Wetlands Inventory). USGS; US Fish and Wildlife Service. vintage not recorded in our database.
[29] Transit schedule (GTFS), weekday 7–9 am service. Pittsburgh Regional Transit. vintage not recorded in our database.
[30] School district and Pittsburgh Public Schools feeder boundaries. Allegheny County; Pittsburgh Public Schools. vintage not recorded in our database.
[31] Building footprints. Allegheny County. vintage not recorded in our database.
[32] Zoning overlays and Registered Community Organizations. City of Pittsburgh. vintage not recorded in our database.
[33] Requirements catalog and rules (EaseScore.AI engine). EaseScore.AI, from the Pittsburgh Code and agency handouts. catalog as of Sept. 2026. Each item cites its code section in Section 5.
[35] Market activity: valid sales and completed building permits within ½ mile, 3 years. Allegheny County sales; City of Pittsburgh PLI permits. computed 2026-09-27. Valid arm's-length sales (price >= $1,000) plus completed building permits in the last 3 years within 1/2 mile, ranked against a fixed 1% sample of City parcels.
[36] Valid sales of new construction (homes built no more than 10 years before the sale). Allegheny County Department of Real Estate sales; Office of Property Assessments (year built, living area). sales through 2026-05-21. Valid arm's-length sales in the last 3 years of homes built no more than 10 years before the sale year, at least 600 sq ft of living area and $20,000, within ±40% of the planned home's size when enough. Same City neighborhood (or municipality) when it has at least 5 such sales, otherwise areas of the same market tier (never a richer market), nearest first; widen from ¼ mile to 3 miles until 8, keep the nearest 12; drop sales beyond 1.5× the middle-half spread of $/SF; at least 5 needed. https://data.wprdc.org/dataset/real-estate-sales
[37] Bank Prime Loan Rate (DPRIME). Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, via FRED. observation 2026-09-21. Construction loan rate = prime + an editable spread. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/DPRIME
[38] Residential building permit base fee: $6.00 per $1,000 of construction value. City of Pittsburgh Permits, Licenses and Inspections (reported). effective 2026-01-01. Verify with the PLI fee schedule; other City fees are not included.
[39] Real estate millage rates (county, municipality, school district). Allegheny County Treasurer. tax year 2026.
[40] Recent Allegheny County housing project costs (total development cost per home). WESA; NEXTpittsburgh; PublicSource (news reports). as reported, 2025–2026. Sanity check only, never a default.
[41] Cost of Constructing a Home 2024. National Association of Home Builders. 2024. National reference, not a Pittsburgh default.
[42] Realty transfer tax rates. PA Department of Revenue; local taxing bodies. vintage not recorded in our database.
sum of positive cash flows ÷ sum of negative cash flows
Years until your cash comes back (payback period)
first month cumulative cash flow ≥ 0, ÷ 12
Project cash flows without a loan (unlevered)
month 0 land; holding spread over approval + construction; hard + soft + contingency spread over construction; then sales after selling costs spread evenly over the sales months
Developer cash flows with the construction loan (levered)
month 0 equity in; then (sales after selling costs − construction loan repayment) spread evenly over the sales months
Rent if every unit is leased, yearly (GPR)
Σ units × monthly rent × 12
Rent you won't collect (vacancy and credit loss)
GPR × vacancy share
Realistic yearly income (EGI)
GPR − vacancy and credit loss + other income
Property taxes, yearly
assessed value × total millage ÷ 1,000
Insurance, yearly (incl. flood and mine subsidence)
month 0 equity in; at completion the permanent loan repays the construction loan (difference to/from equity); then NOI ÷ 12 − loan payment each month; sale proceeds − loan balance in the last month
Returns are computed from monthly cash flows; a yearly rate = (1 + monthly rate)^12 − 1. Property tax = assessed value × mills ÷ 1,000. Mine subsidence insurance = $3.75 + $0.25 per $1,000 of coverage[45].
[11]
Architecture and engineering
8%
5%–12%
Assumption — editable — Custom and hillside projects sit at the high end. The Production (spec) tier uses stock plans: 3% (its own default).[6]
Pittsburgh residential building permit fee
$6 per $1,000 (0.6%)
—
Pittsburgh PLI residential base permit fee (verify with PLI schedule) — Reported base fee effective 2026-01-01. Other City fees (zoning, plan review add-ons, DOMI) are not included.[38]
Survey, title, legal and builder's risk insurance
3%
2%–5%
Assumption — editable[6]
General contractor fee (only when trade-level costs are entered)
not applied (15% when used)
12%–18%
Assumption — editable — Not applied to the base tiers, which already include builder overhead and profit.[6]
Contingency (flat lot, new build)
7%
—
Assumption — editable[6]
Months to approval
1
—
Ease Score months to a permit[5]
Months to build
9
—
Assumption — editable[6]
Property taxes while holding, monthly
$5
—
County assessment × total millage (County Treasurer)[14]
Construction loan rate
8%
—
Bank prime rate (FRED DPRIME) + assumption — Prime 7% on 2026-09-21 + 1% (Assumption — editable)[37]
Construction loan as a share of cost (LTC)
80%
—
Assumption — editable[6]
Average share of the loan drawn while building
50%
—
Assumption — editable — Draws rise from zero to the full loan, so the average balance is about half.[6]
Lender fees as a share of the loan
1%
—
Assumption — editable[6]
Sale price per finished sq ft
$271/SF
—
Allegheny County sales (valid new-construction comps) — Median of 11 new-construction sales within 2 mi (2023-12-13 to 2026-05-21)[36]
Broker commission and closing costs (share of sale price)
5%
—
Assumption — editable[6]
Seller's share of the realty transfer tax
2.5% (half of 5%)
—
Transfer tax rates (PA Dept. of Revenue, local) — Pennsylvania custom splits the transfer tax evenly; the rate comes from our transfer tax data.[42]
Months to sell after completion
3
—
Assumption — editable[6]
Bedrooms per home (rent)
3
—
Assumption, edit me — Default mix by option: single-family, duplex and townhouse 3 bedrooms; 3–4 unit building 2; ADU 1[6]
Monthly rent per home
$1,750
—
HUD Small Area Fair Market Rent FY2026, ZIP 15212 (benchmark, not listings) — 3-bedroom home: HUD Small Area Fair Market Rent FY2026, ZIP 15212 (benchmark, not listings)[34]
Not set yet (no default, so never counted): market cap rate, discount rate, hold period and exit cap rate (rental returns), permanent loan terms, minimum debt coverage. Items that apply but have no local cost are listed in Section 7 as not included.
Table 34. Construction cost tiers (per finished sq ft, including builder overhead and profit)[11]
Tier
What it means
Range
Default
Production (spec)
Stock plans from a production or spec builder
$165–$205
$185
Basic
Stock plans, builder-grade finishes (spec and production builders)
$175–$225
$200
Good spec (used)
Clean modern finishes, efficient plan
$225–$275
$250
Better
Upgraded finishes, some custom millwork
$275–$350
$310
High-end
Architect-designed, premium materials
$350–$450
$400
Custom
Fully bespoke; the top of the range is open-ended (600 and up)
$450–$600+
$525
Site adders on top of the tier: moderate slope (8–25%) +$20 per sq ft of building footprint (range $10–$35); steep slope or stepped foundation +$45 per sq ft of footprint (range $30–$70) plus retaining walls $15,000 per building, all “Assumption, edit me”; mine grouting $40,000 (range $30,000–$50,000), “Local project data (owner-provided)”; geotechnical report, demolition and dumpsters: awaiting local cost data[6].
Accessory dwelling unit (ADU)
n/a
Not applicable
Rehab of the existing building
n/a
Not applicable
Table 37. Policy what-ifs: change in the best score and in homes allowed by right
Policy change
Score change
Homes change
Note
Parking minimum removed
0
+2
Minimum lot size removed
0
0
Attached housing by right
0
0
Contextual front setback applied
0
0
Absorption and lease-up data: Months to sell or lease up are editable assumptions (Section 6), supported only by counts of nearby sales, not a market study.
Which water utility serves the lot: Fees assume Pittsburgh Water (PWSA); some City neighborhoods are served by Pennsylvania American Water.
Steep areas in the buildable area: The site-fit solver does not yet remove slopes over 25% from the buildable area, so it may place a building on steep ground.
Surveyed lot lines and frontage: Lot lines and frontage come from GIS, not a survey.
22 of the cited sources do not yet have a data date recorded in our database (see Appendix A).
Use of AI
No number in this study comes from an AI model. All numbers are computed by deterministic code from the cited data. The plain-English sentences in this version are written from fixed templates. The EaseScore.AI product was built with the help of AI coding tools, disclosed in the project README.
No personal information (owner names or contact details) is used or shown.
NPV (net present value)
Today’s value of all future cash flows minus what you put in.
Pro forma
A projection of a project’s costs, income and returns.
Setback
The required distance between a building and a lot line.
Soft costs
Costs that are not physical construction: design, engineering, permits, legal, insurance.
Special exception
A use the Zoning Board can allow after a hearing if set conditions are met.
TDC (total development cost)
Everything it costs to buy, build and finance the project.
Undermined
Land above old underground mines, which can settle (subsidence).
Variance
Permission from the Zoning Board to break a written rule, usually for a hardship.
Yield on cost
Yearly net income divided by total development cost.
